Landowners forced to split plots when updating land use certificates face legal and practical hurdles

In recent months, a growing number of property owners across Vietnam have reported encountering bureaucratic resistance when attempting to update their Land Use Rights Certificates (LURCs), commonly known as "red books." The core of the issue lies in local land administration authorities mandating the compulsory separation of adjacent land plots into individual certificates whenever a owner seeks to change the land use purpose for a portion of their property. This practice, which often forces landowners to fragment their holdings against their will, has raised significant concerns regarding property rights, land management efficiency, and the potential for future transactional difficulties.
The Case Study: A Property Owner’s Dilemma
The situation is exemplified by the experience of a landowner in Hai Phong (formerly Hai Duong province). In 2004, the local People’s Committee issued a single LURC for a total area of 800 square meters. This parcel comprised two contiguous plots within a single residential complex: Plot 304, covering 600 square meters (split between residential and garden land), and Plot 309, consisting of 200 square meters of pond land.
Decades later, the owner sought to convert 300 square meters of the garden land within Plot 304 into residential land. Upon submitting the application, local officials informed the owner that the administrative procedure required not only an update to the "new model" of the LURC but also the mandatory separation of Plot 304 and Plot 309 into two distinct certificates. The justification provided by the local office was that, under current administrative practices, every individual land plot must be issued a separate certificate, regardless of whether the plots are contiguous or held within a single, unified estate.
The landowner expressed deep concern regarding this requirement, particularly regarding the 200-square-meter pond plot. Separating the pond into a standalone certificate could render it functionally isolated, as it lacks a dedicated access point to a public road, potentially complicating any future sale or transfer of the property.
Legal Context and Regulatory Framework
To address the mounting confusion, legal experts have scrutinized the 2024 Land Law and related legislative documents to determine if such mandatory separation is legally sound. Attorney Nguyen Van Hau, Chairman of the Vietnam Legal Experts Association, emphasizes that there is currently no legal basis to force a landowner to split contiguous plots simply because they are undergoing a change in land use purpose or an administrative update.
The distinction between "updating a certificate" and "splitting a land plot" is critical. According to Clause 2, Article 220 of the 2024 Land Law and Clause 3, Article 11 of the 2025 National Assembly Resolution No. 254, the conversion of a portion of a land plot’s use purpose does not necessitate the formal splitting of the plot. Furthermore, Clause 1, Part C, Section V of the Appendix I to Decree 151/2025 clarifies that for existing certificates issued for multiple plots, authorities should accommodate the owner’s request for individual certificates rather than imposing them.

Chronology of Administrative Shifts
The evolution of land documentation in Vietnam has seen several shifts that contribute to the current friction:
- Pre-2004: Many land parcels were granted under older, less standardized documentation systems.
- 2004–2010: The period during which the subject property was issued its initial unified LURC, reflecting the practice of grouping contiguous plots under one administrative header for ease of record-keeping.
- 2024–2025: The implementation of the new Land Law (2024) aimed to modernize land administration. However, the transition period has led to inconsistent interpretations by local-level officials, who are prioritizing the digitization and standardization of the national database over the practical needs of individual landowners.
Implications for Property Owners
The push for mandatory separation creates several adverse implications for the public:
- Fragmentation of Utility: By splitting a larger, unified plot, owners may find that certain sections, such as ponds or garden areas, lose their direct connection to infrastructure, such as water supply, drainage, or road access.
- Increased Transaction Costs: Each separate certificate incurs its own administrative fees and potentially higher tax valuations if the land classification is altered during the separation process.
- Future Marketability: A "trapped" plot—one without legal access or attached to a larger, more viable parcel—becomes significantly less attractive to potential buyers, potentially lowering the overall market value of the estate.
Official Responses and Expert Advice
Legal practitioners advise that landowners facing such demands from local authorities should not feel coerced into compliance. Attorney Dang Thi Thuy Huyen, Director of HPL Law Firm, warns that property owners must be particularly cautious when local officials cite "modernization" as a justification for splitting plots. Under Article 220 of the 2024 Land Law, any land partition must guarantee the feasibility of continued use, including established access to public roads and utility connections.
Legal experts recommend the following steps for those facing similar obstacles:
- Maintain Unified Documentation: Submit the original 2004 LURC alongside the current land survey as evidence of the existing, consolidated status of the land.
- Formal Written Request: Explicitly request that the administrative update be performed without the separation of the plots, citing the lack of requirement in the 2024 Land Law.
- Demand Written Justification: If an official insists on separation, the landowner has the right to request a written response detailing the specific legal provision that makes such a split mandatory.
- Escalation: If the administrative body continues to force the issue without a valid legal basis, the landowner reserves the right to file an administrative complaint or petition the higher-level authorities for a review of the decision.
Broader Analysis: The Balance Between Standardization and Utility
The tension between the government’s desire for a standardized, digital land database and the traditional, integrated nature of land ownership in Vietnam is a hallmark of the current transition period. While the government aims to ensure that every plot has a unique identifier to facilitate clearer tax collection and urban planning, this objective must be balanced against the rights of the citizen to enjoy their property as it was legally acquired.
Experts argue that the "one size fits all" approach adopted by some local officials is a misinterpretation of the spirit of the 2024 Land Law. The legislation is designed to empower owners to manage their land efficiently, not to restrict them through arbitrary administrative hurdles. As the country continues to refine its land administration processes, it is expected that the central government will issue more stringent guidance to local committees to prevent overreach and ensure that the modernization of the land registry does not come at the expense of the landowners it is intended to serve.
Ultimately, the case serves as a reminder of the importance of legal literacy in property management. Landowners are encouraged to remain vigilant, insist on compliance with the current Land Law, and seek legal counsel when local administrative requirements appear to conflict with their property rights. As the digital transition proceeds, clear communication between citizens and officials will be essential to ensure that the process of updating "red books" remains a service to the public rather than a source of unnecessary hardship.







