PGS Nguyen Viet Nhung: Vietnam needs to build a tobacco-free generation

The proposal to implement a lifetime ban on the sale of tobacco products to individuals born on or after January 1, 2010, has sparked a significant national debate in Vietnam, drawing attention from policymakers, public health experts, and the general public. This legislative concept, often referred to as the "Tobacco-Free Generation" (TFG) strategy, was introduced during the November 2024 discussions regarding amendments to the Law on Prevention and Control of Tobacco Harms. The proposal, championed by National Assembly member Le Hoang Anh, suggests that starting in 2028, the sale and supply of tobacco to anyone born after 2010 should be permanently prohibited, regardless of their age at the time of purchase.
This policy shift represents a radical departure from traditional tobacco control measures, which typically focus on age restrictions, taxation, and public health awareness campaigns. By creating a sliding cutoff date, the policy aims to eventually phase out the legal tobacco market entirely for future generations.
Scientific Foundations and Medical Perspective
PGS.TS.BS Nguyen Viet Nhung, Vice President of the Vietnam Medical Association and former Director of the National Lung Hospital, emphasizes that while the proposal is grounded in a logical scientific framework, its implementation requires a rigorous, multi-dimensional assessment. From a clinical perspective, Dr. Nhung has spent decades treating patients suffering from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and lung cancer, conditions directly linked to long-term tobacco consumption.
"I have witnessed the devastating reality of patients who must live with chronic respiratory failure and the trauma of families exhausting their life savings to care for loved ones with terminal illnesses," Dr. Nhung noted. He stresses that the TFG model targets the root cause—preventing the initiation of smoking among youth—rather than merely managing the medical consequences once addiction has taken hold.
The scientific basis for this model rests on three pillars: the neurobiology of nicotine addiction, the age of initiation, and the cumulative impact of long-term exposure. Nicotine is highly addictive, particularly for adolescents whose brains are still in a critical developmental phase. Research consistently shows that the vast majority of regular smokers begin their habit during their teenage years. By preventing the formation of nicotine dependence at a young age, the policy aims to break the cycle of addiction before it starts. Furthermore, the risk of developing fatal diseases such as lung cancer and cardiovascular disease increases with the duration of smoking. By delaying or preventing the start of smoking, the total "pack-years" of exposure over a lifetime are significantly reduced.
Global Context and Policy Evolution
Vietnam is not the first nation to explore such bold legislative action. The global landscape of tobacco control has seen a variety of approaches, each offering lessons for Vietnam. New Zealand, for instance, passed landmark legislation in 2022 that would have implemented a generational tobacco ban, combined with measures to reduce the number of retail outlets and lower the nicotine content in tobacco products. However, the legislation was repealed in 2024 following a change in government, highlighting the vulnerability of such ambitious policies to political shifts and the necessity of broad social consensus.
In contrast, the United Kingdom has taken a different path. In April 2026, the UK enacted the Tobacco and Vapes Bill, which sets a legal precedent to ban the sale of tobacco to anyone born on or after January 1, 2009, with the prohibition taking effect from January 1, 2027. Singapore, another leader in public health, has opted for a different strategy by incrementally raising the minimum legal age for tobacco purchase to 21, coupled with strict controls on e-cigarettes and nicotine delivery systems.
These global examples underscore that there is no "one-size-fits-all" solution. The success of any TFG policy depends heavily on the robustness of the legal framework, the capacity for enforcement, and the political will to sustain the policy over decades.

Economic and Public Health Implications
According to data from the World Health Organization (WHO), tobacco consumption in Vietnam is responsible for more than 100,000 deaths annually. Beyond the loss of life, the economic burden is estimated at approximately 108 trillion VND each year. These costs include direct healthcare expenses for treating tobacco-related diseases and the indirect loss of economic productivity due to illness and premature mortality.
A 2024 study published in The Lancet Public Health modeled the impact of eliminating tobacco use among cohorts born between 2006 and 2010 across 185 countries. The projections suggested that up to 1.19 million lung cancer deaths could be averted by 2095, representing a 40.2% reduction in predicted lung cancer mortality for that group. While these figures are based on modeling, they demonstrate the immense potential of preventing youth smoking initiation.
However, Dr. Nhung warns against viewing this as a simple administrative fix. "A good policy must reduce the burden on public health while simultaneously addressing the economic and social realities of the transition," he stated. This includes considering the livelihoods of those currently employed in the tobacco supply chain, including farmers and retail workers. A comprehensive strategy must include vocational training and economic transition plans for these groups to ensure that public health goals do not create unnecessary social hardship.
Challenges in Enforcement and Implementation
One of the most significant concerns for Vietnamese authorities is the current effectiveness of enforcement regarding existing age restrictions. Since 2012, Vietnam has prohibited the sale of tobacco to individuals under the age of 18, yet violations remain widespread. Critics argue that layering a new, more complex generational ban on top of an existing, poorly enforced system might lead to a "black market" boom rather than a decrease in smoking rates.
To address this, Dr. Nhung proposes a three-pronged approach to bolster enforcement:
- Strengthening Retail Control: Rigorous oversight of retail locations, strict licensing requirements, and severe penalties for non-compliance are essential.
- Technological Integration: Utilizing digitized identity systems to verify age at the point of sale could streamline compliance. However, this must be balanced with robust data privacy protections to prevent the abuse of personal information.
- Combating Illicit Trade: The government must simultaneously control the illicit trade of tobacco and the rise of alternative products like e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products. If traditional cigarettes are banned for a specific group, the policy will fail if that group simply switches to more easily accessible, potentially equally harmful, unregulated products.
The Path Forward for Vietnam
Vietnam is already on a trajectory to strengthen its tobacco control framework. The country is a party to the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) and has committed to various measures, including a roadmap for increasing tobacco taxes starting in 2027 and the proposed ban on e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products from 2025.
The consensus among experts is that Vietnam should focus on the effective implementation of existing laws before adding new, complex layers. The transition toward a "tobacco-free generation" must be driven by evidence-based data rather than subjective aspirations. Before any law is enacted, extensive surveys, social impact assessments, and pilot programs are necessary to determine the feasibility of the proposal in the local context.
"The goal is not just to pass a law, but to create a societal shift where the next generation naturally views tobacco as a thing of the past," says Dr. Nhung. He advocates for a cautious but steady approach that prioritizes the creation of smoke-free environments and the enforcement of current age limits. By building a foundation of public support and institutional capacity, Vietnam can ensure that if it chooses to adopt a generational ban, it will be a durable policy that saves lives for generations to come.
Ultimately, the debate is a testament to Vietnam’s growing commitment to public health. Whether or not a formal lifetime ban is adopted, the discourse itself serves as a vital tool in raising awareness about the long-term dangers of tobacco and the responsibility the current generation holds in protecting the health and economic future of the next. The legacy of today’s policy decisions will be measured not in the immediate reduction of smokers, but in the long-term, measurable decline in the prevalence of chronic, life-threatening diseases among the youth of tomorrow.







